On Not Belonging

Have you ever been in a room full of people including those you know, surrounded by conversations and laughter, and somehow felt like you were standing on the outside looking in?
Or quietly observing everyone else, wondering how they seem to be so at ease with themselves, while you’re never quite sure where you fit?
Have you ever found yourself adjusting your personality, opinions, or behaviors to suit who you’re with?
Perhaps you’ve come home from a gathering feeling strangely disconnected, even when nothing particularly unpleasant happened.
And maybe even questioned whether there’s something you’re not doing right.
I know that feeling.
When I came across this book (The Gift of Not Belonging) the other day, I was intrigued. It touched on something I’ve wrestled with for most of my life. But I never saw it as a gift.
In fact, the writer, Rami Kaminski, MD, even has a name for people who experience the world this way: an otrovert! While I didn’t resonate with everything the book has to say, I found myself relating to so many experiences I’d lived through but never quite had the words to describe.
For most of my life, I’ve felt like an outsider. Quietly observing, never quite feeling like I fully fit in. At least not authentically. Not back in my home country and the Asian culture I grew up in, nor here in the Western culture where I’ve been building my life as an immigrant.
I’ve always thought, and in some ways learned to accept, that perhaps it was because I was an introvert. But that explanation never quite captured the loneliness and feeling of not being fully understood that often came with it.
“…otroverts are emotional loners – they feel the most alone when surrounded by others.”
Yes. And for a long time, I thought the problem was with me.
Being socially awkward. Not knowing how to join in or naturally connect with others. I avoided social gatherings whenever I could because I didn’t want to experience that familiar feeling that I was somehow different. Two years ago, starting my own business required me to face that discomfort, whether I liked it or not.
But over the years, something has shifted for me.
Lately, I’ve noticed that even when I’m the one initiating social gatherings, I still find myself observing a little more than participating. But there is one important difference.
Now, it no longer leaves me feeling lonely or misunderstood.
It’s not because I’ve suddenly changed who I am. If anything, I’m now more able to experience who I am, from a different place. A place anchored deep within me. A place of connection with myself that I’ve learned to return to.
As I reflect on this, two things stand out for me.
Firstly, our idea of what it means to belong.
I wonder how many of us have spent years searching for a sense of belonging without really stopping to question what belonging actually means to us.
For many of us, we have come to learn that belonging means being accepted by a group. Having people to identify with. People who share similar values, beliefs, interests, and ways of living. Knowing that we’re part of something and that there’s a place for us. There is nothing inherently wrong with that.
As humans, we all have an innate need for connection. From the moment we’re born, we depend on others for safety, nourishment, and care. As humans, we’re wired for attachment and the security that comes from knowing we’re not alone.
But somewhere along the way, I wonder if we’ve confused belonging with fitting in. That our communal societies have reinforced the idea that belonging means being part of a group, much like our ancestors relied on their tribes for protection and survival.
While we may no longer need a tribe to protect us in the same way, we still need to navigate the experience of being human. And there’s comfort in knowing that we have a place among others. Sharing a common understanding of the world and feeling that we’re part of something bigger than ourselves offers us a form of protection, even if it sometimes may be an illusionary one.
Perhaps this is why so many of us have learned to adapt, conform, and sometimes suppress parts of ourselves to sustain that sense of connection.
But what if this sense of connection we seek through belonging comes with conditions?
I remember being at a retreat two years ago. During one of our small morning circles, I shared that I didn’t feel like I belonged there, even among people I thought would be like-minded (which I later discovered wasn’t necessarily the case!). I didn’t feel like I fit in. Someone gently reminded me that perhaps fitting in wasn’t really what I was seeking.
I didn’t quite know what to make of that at the time. But it stayed with me.
“Most of the discomfort originates from trying to fit in and play a role that is expected of them, a performance otroverts find exhausting.”
It made me wonder how many of us have mistaken belonging for fitting in. How often have we held ourselves back to avoid being different from everyone else? Changed the way we expressed ourselves to avoid being misunderstood? Or said yes to something simply because we didn’t want to be the odd one out? Perhaps even questioned our own feelings because everyone else seemed to see things differently.
I know I have.
And I wonder how much of what we call belonging is actually conditional acceptance. An unspoken understanding that we’re part of the group as long as we choose not to deviate too far from what’s acceptable and expected of us.
I wonder how while our need for connection is real, our learned ideas and beliefs about how we need to belong may be what limits us.
The more I’m open to looking at our human experience from a wider perspective, the more I wonder whether what we’re really longing for isn’t necessarily belonging to a group, but the safety that comes from being deeply connected to others. As described by Deb Dana in her book Anchored, we humans long not only to feel safe, but to feel safe in the arms of another.
Perhaps this need for deep connection is meant to soften the harsh truth of being human, that in many ways, we each experience life as individuals, and ultimately alone.
And yet, somewhere along the way, we’ve come to believe that to feel less alone, we need to belong in a certain way.
But what if true connection doesn’t require us to fit in?
What if we can be deeply connected to others without needing to be similar?
Secondly, what if not belonging isn’t something that needs to be fixed?
I suspect many, myself included, have learned to abandon parts of who we are in exchange for a sense of belonging. An entry pass into whatever tribe we wish to be accepted in.
But what happens when we spend so much of our lives trying to be accepted by others that we slowly lose connection with ourselves?
For me, this has been a very uncomfortable place to be in. Not knowing where I belonged. Not feeling entirely comfortable in my own skin.
Not Asian enough, but not quite Western either.
Feeling caught somewhere in between, carrying pieces of different cultures but never quite feeling fully at home in either.
It wasn’t just about culture. It showed up in the way I related to people, the conversations I carry, the things I believed in, and the way I expressed myself. I had learned so many ideas, beliefs, and communal values about what it meant to be one or the other. But very little of it came from knowing who I was as an individual in my own right.
Even expressing my thoughts through writing or showing up on social media was a challenge. I’ve never quite felt the desire to join in with the collective conversation. And I’ve often found myself questioning whether there was something I was missing. Something everyone else seemed to understand that I didn’t.
Not until I finally began experiencing what it means to reconnect with myself through my own journey of returning home. Of being comfortable with who I am, even if it means going against the grain. Of finding my own way of expressing who I am that feels honest, even when it can sometimes be challenging.
As I’m finding a new way to be me in the world we live in today, I’m beginning to claim a different kind of freedom. The freedom to embrace perhaps the otrovert in me.
“Instead of learning to belong, the otrovert’s goal should be to understand their true strengths and limitations and develop a keen appreciation for themselves.”
For one, I’m learning to appreciate my need for solitude. The writer describes this as having a rich inner world, a place to retreat from the noise and expectations of the collective. A place that belongs to you, and you alone.
For me, that place has taken on a different meaning over time. It’s no longer just a place in my mind where I retreat when the outside world gets too loud. It’s something I can now experience in an embodied way.
One that I find in moments when I look up at the sky and find myself smiling. When I feel the freshness of the air against my skin. When I hear the crunch of dried leaves and gravel beneath my feet and feel more present.
Sometimes I laugh. Sometimes I cry. Sometimes I sing out loud. And sometimes I simply be with whatever is there.
There’s a kind of fullness in these seemingly ordinary moments that’s difficult to explain.
Perhaps that is what I’m beginning to understand about embracing my rich inner world, even when it may look different from the world around me.
It isn’t about withdrawing from life because it doesn’t fit. It’s about discovering a way of experiencing life that feels deeply connected to who I am, and from which I can allow myself to choose how I want to show up in the world.
I’m also learning to appreciate the deep, genuine conversations I crave with a select few people who can meet me where I am. Not because I’m socially awkward or incapable of holding surface-level conversations. But because I’ve come to embrace the value of being intentional about how I connect with others. And learning that there is nothing wrong about that.
So, how is this a gift, you may wonder?
Perhaps being able to experience the world differently, even when it’s not how most people experience it, can be a gift when we’re able to stop seeing it as something that needs to be fixed. When we learn to appreciate what it offers rather than constantly comparing against how others live, connect, or belong.
And it is a gift for me. Because if it weren’t for the nagging feeling, that constant questioning of where I belonged, perhaps I wouldn’t have found my way back home. To the place where I belong, unconditionally and eternally. Within.
A couple of months ago, while cozying up in bed with me, my daughter shared how she felt about not belonging in her group of friends.
My heart ached for her.
Because I know that feeling so well. I know how lonely and confusing it can be to wonder why you don’t quite fit in, especially when it seems like everyone else has found their place.
I wanted to comfort her. To tell her that she doesn’t need to change who she is to be accepted. That she doesn’t have to become someone else just to have a place among others.
But I also know there are some experiences and lessons in life that she will have to discover for herself.
All I can do is be a steady anchor for her to return to. A safe place where she doesn’t have to perform, prove anything, or be anyone other than herself. Where she knows she is loved, just as she is. Where she can experience being deeply connected within and with us.
And perhaps, in time, she’ll discover that belonging doesn’t have to begin with finding the right group of people. It can begin with knowing that she never has to abandon herself to be in one.
But I don’t always get it right. Because I too am finding my way. And I’m learning to appreciate this precious gift of finding our ways together.
So, my wish for you, just as it is for my daughter and myself, is that whether you’re an otrovert, introvert, extrovert, or somewhere in between; whether you’re neurotypical, neurodivergent, or somewhere along that spectrum; whatever the color of your skin, and wherever you come from; may you experience what it means to be embraced for who you are.
By the people around you, but most of all, by yourself.
May you find the freedom to be who you are without constantly questioning whether you fit in. To connect with others without disconnecting from yourself in the process. And to know that you don’t have to belong anywhere to feel at home somewhere.
Perhaps the gift of not belonging isn’t about being different or learning to find comfort or strength in being an outsider.
Perhaps it’s about no longer needing to find a place in the world at the expense of the place we already have within ourselves.
And from that place, we can begin to meet the world, and one another, a little more honestly, and a little more freely.
Wouldn’t that be great?
Note: Words and excerpts taken from The Gift of Not Belonging by Rami Kaminski, MD are shown in sage green and rose italics.
.png)


Comments